Choose Ratings to View:  Overall Batters  | SP  | RP  | C  | 1B  | 2B  | 3B  | SS  | OF  | DH  | Summary
Starting PitcherRating = QS + 20/(ERA+1) + 20/(WHIP+1)
Highest Starting Pitcher Ratings (Historical)
Based on 2026 Rating Definitions; 100 Innings Pitched Minimum
Season Player Team (Owner) POS $ SP Rating
1 2015 Greinke, Zack bonus Leaders (James Nickras) SP $1.90 48.371
2 2015 Arrieta, Jake bonus Leaders (James Nickras) SP $1.00 46.950
3 2018 deGrom, Jacob bonus Ghastly Monsters (Herold Lutz) SP $3.00 45.864
4 2014 Cueto, Johnny bonus Fantasy Bust Pile (Tim Davis) SP $2.30 45.372
5 2013 Kershaw, Clayton bonus The Intentional Walking Dead (Chad Dye) SP $3.00 44.508
6 2018 Scherzer, Max bonus Hardcore for the Hardcap (Nate Chipley) SP $2.30 44.134
7 2015 Kershaw, Clayton bonus Heroes (Herold Lutz) SP $5.00 44.027
8 2007 Peavy, Jake Leaders (James Nickras) SP $1.50 43.355
9 2008 Santana, Johan Nonbillable Hours (Brad Adamsky) SP $4.10 42.969
10 2021 Buehler, Walker bonus Evil Empire (Brandon Knight) SP $2.00 42.926
11 2005 Clemens, Roger Chad's Slightly Below Average Team (Chad Dye) SP $1.00 42.920
12 2005 Pettitte, Andy Chad's Slightly Below Average Team (Chad Dye) SP $1.40 42.755
13 2012 Dickey, R.A. bonus Heroes (Herold Lutz) SP $0.60 42.098
14 2004 Johnson, Randy Bastards (Tim Davis) SP $2.20 42.082
15 2005 Carpenter, Chris Swinging Richards (Tony Spahr) SP $1.40 41.953
16 2024 Wheeler, Zach bonus Baseball Bashers ⚾️⚾️⚾️⚾️⚾️ (Jason Davis) SP $1.80 41.840
17 2016 Lester, Jon bonus Billable Hours (Brad Adamsky) SP $2.50 41.728
18 2009 Lincecum, Tim bonus Stars and Turds (Brad Adamsky) SP $1.00 41.522
19 2011 Kershaw, Clayton bonus Nonbillable Hours (Brad Adamsky) SP $1.50 41.221
20 2016 Scherzer, Max bonus The Balking Dead (Chad Dye) SP $1.00 41.219
21 2018 Nola, Aaron bonus Hardcore for the Hardcap (Nate Chipley) SP $1.00 41.056
22 2014 Kershaw, Clayton bonus The Intentional Walking Dead (Chad Dye) SP $4.00 40.990
23 2011 Halladay, Roy bonus Chad's Fantastic Team (Chad Dye) SP $1.50 40.775
24 2014 Wainwright, Adam bonus Jobu's Juggernauts (Nate Chipley) SP $1.50 40.767
25 2011 Cain, Matt bonus Chad's Fantastic Team (Chad Dye) SP $1.70 40.754
Highest Starting Pitcher Ratings (Current Season)
Based on 2026 Rating Definitions; 100 Innings Pitched Minimum
Season Player Team (Owner) POS $ SP Rating
1 2026 Yamamoto, Yoshinobu bonus Horton Hears Your Excuses (Brandon Knight) SP $2.00 38.360
2 2026 Misiorowski, Jacob bonus Jason T (Jason Thompson) SP $1.00 36.236
3 2026 Sanchez, Cristopher bonus Victor Von Doom (Chad Dye) SP $1.00 36.190
4 2026 Sale, Chris bonus Poe's Law (Brad Adamsky) SP $1.80 35.416
5 2026 Alcantara, Sandy Jason T (Jason Thompson) SP $1.10 34.080
6 2026 McLean, Nolan Victor Von Doom (Chad Dye) SP $1.00 34.034
7 2026 Rodriguez, Eduardo Jason T (Jason Thompson) SP $1.00 33.068
8 2026 Cavalli, Cade Lead Balloons (James Nickras) SP $0.50 32.251
9 2026 King, Michael Lead Balloons (James Nickras) SP $1.10 31.931
10 2026 Luzardo, Jesus Victor Von Doom (Chad Dye) SP $1.60 31.830
Highest Average Starting Pitcher Ratings (Historical)
Based on 2026 Rating Definitions; 100 Innings Pitched Required for Eligible Season; Minimum of 3 Eligible Seasons
Seasons Player Eligible
Seasons
Average
Rating
Lowest
Rating
Highest
Rating
1 2011-2013 Lee, Cliff 3 38.3803 35.2737 40.7511
2 2005-2007 Smoltz, John 3 37.6261 35.2537 40.0377
3 2014-2019 deGrom, Jacob 6 36.6577 30.0296 45.8640
4 2004-2011 Carpenter, Chris 6 36.6285 31.8401 41.9530
5 2010-2012 Halladay, Roy 3 36.3431 27.6446 40.7752
6 2004-2006 Clemens, Roger 3 36.0229 27.8535 42.9201
7 2011-2017 Dickey, R.A. 3 35.6664 29.2444 42.0981
8 2011-2015 Zimmermann, Jordan 5 35.6316 30.1016 39.1189
9 2003-2008 Webb, Brandon 6 35.5405 31.3407 37.7469
10 2022-2025 Webb, Logan 4 35.2137 33.3882 38.3487
11 2009-2025 Kershaw, Clayton 15 34.8538 19.6178 44.5083
12 2003-2011 Vazquez, Javier 4 34.5666 32.4242 37.0373
13 2021-2023 Burnes, Corbin 3 34.5400 33.2205 36.2517
14 2006-2012 Johnson, Josh 4 34.5153 27.5814 38.5550
15 2003-2011 Oswalt, Roy 9 34.4393 26.8176 39.2486